Showing posts with label Samantha. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Samantha. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

Stephen D(a)edalus: Loner or Liberator?

Yet, for all his lonely self-assertion, Stephen recognizes himself to be a member of a community; it is in relation to the collective, the race, that he formulates his individual aspiration. (vii)

With the obvious allusion to the overreaching Greek hero Daedalus, our young protagonist comes to us as not quite straightforward a hero-to-be. Contrary to his claim that as a liberator of his race he wanted to “forge…the uncreated conscience of [his] race” (pg), Stephen hardly exhibits traits of a liberator. A voluntary social loner instead, he is deeply alienated from his family, friends, and in a larger sense, the Irish community. Yet despite his attempt to assert his individual identity, Stephen finds himself deeply embedded within the “nets” of “nationality, language, [and] religion” (220). For example, he excels in English, writing poetry and essays well, yet recognizes that English is the language of the British colonizers:

The language in which we are speaking is his before it is mine…I cannot speak or write these words without unrest of spirit. His language, so familiar and so foreign, will always be for me an acquired speech. I have not made or accepted its words. My voice holds them at bay. My soul frets in the shadow of his language. (205)

As for religion, at beginning of Part III, Stephen keeps going back to visit the prostitutes, “prowl[ing] in quest of that call” (109), yet he has a sense that this is sinful: “He had sinned mortally not once but many times and he knew that, while he stood in danger of eternal damnation for the first sin alone, by every succeeding sin he multiplied his guilt and his punishment” (110). When Father Arnall gives his sermon, Stephen is greatly affected, unlike the other boys, driving deeper his loner status at the same time inscribing him deeper into this “net” of Irish nationality.

I guess ultimately my post this week comes as a set of questions: (1) can we really take Stephen to be the liberator of his race, and (2) can Stephen’s grappling with these “nets” be allegorical of a nation trying to break free from its British/Roman past, if after all, Stephen’s struggles are also very much personal ones? If so, (3) how fit is the character of Stephen for this hero/liberator role, if he is so deeply embedded in these very “nets” that he is trying to fly free from?

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

(Not at) Home Away from Home: Out of Country, Out of Character

Woolf's “Jaffna”, like “Shooting an Elephant”, is centred on and driven by a main protagonist, typically an average-rank official: an insider to the Empire, yet one who looks in from the outside. Like the elephant-shooting official, who is forced to operate as an automaton within the imperialist system, of which flaws and motives he recognises, so also Woolf saw imperialism from the outside in and “gradually became fully aware of its nature and problems”. While such self-awareness might be praised, it in fact detaches characters (and authors?) from responsibility for the ills of empire while they yet remain in it.

Interestingly, the authors we’ve been reading tend to pad their characters’ actions by contrasting home and being “out there” (Heart of Darkness 17). Woolf tellingly opens the “Jaffna” section by disclaiming that

If one lives where one was born and bred, the continuity of one’s existence gives it…accepted reality. But if…one suddenly uproots oneself into a strange land and a strange life, one feels as if one were acting…or…in a dream.


Also, the characters in Heart of Darkness and Burmese Days are so unnerved by being in foreign lands that they just can’t function in character, conveniently accounting for their exploitative and cruel acts.

From the realm of the caves, Forster’s words echo thus: “We’re not pleasant in India, and we don’t intend to be pleasant. We’ve something more important to do” (Passage 45). Contrary to Fielding’s quip that “You can make India in England apparently, just as you can make England in India” (67), the impulse to detach characters and their motives from their actions with the "out-of-country, out-of-character” mentality prove otherwise – you can’t make England anywhere else than England – and betray the nagging need to account for the vast number of crimes committed in the name of colonialism.

(300 words)

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

White Identity at Peril

A classic illustration of white supremacy in Burmese Days found me rather vexed when I got to the part where Maxwell had just been murdered. As the Club men began plotting their revenge, the native’s life is portrayed as cheaper than a white man’s, like in exchange rates: “two corpses against their one – best we can do” (219), as if life can be valued in the first place. The natives understand the double-standards of the colonial rule they are under: aware that the four boys, wrongly accused for attacking Ellis, were not likely to be given fair trial, they decide to take things into their own hands and stage a revolt at the Club. Stoler highlights a similar double-standard regarding inter-marriages, showing how European men who marry native women are merely seen as indulging in sexual excess, while the native women are always assumed to be either prostitutes or concubines.

These double-standards, instead of solidifying white supremacy, actually cast light on the frail justifications for white supremacy and the fragility of the “essence” (Stoler 516) of European-ness. For example, such métis’ (persons of mixed parentage) “ambiguous positioning and identifications” (516) were regarded as potentially disloyal threats to the colonial state. Further, that they can be classified as Europeans by association with their fathers does well to upset the “purity of the [colonial] community” (516), and race is no longer the stable or adequate marker of colonial difference. Fears then emerged that a European man might lose his “identity and would become degenerate and décivilisé” (534), and this leads me to conclude that the imposition of white supremacy by colonial rulers on colonised subjects was symptomatic of white identity at peril: colonisers were beginning to realise the fluidity of their white “essence”, which undermined the justification for colonialism – race as colonial difference.

(300 words)

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Topsy-Turvy

I found Flory and Veraswami’s friendship reminiscent of Aziz and Fielding in Passage. Both Flory and Veraswami respect and enjoy engaging each other in civil conversation. Flory especially seems to appreciate this aspect of their friendship, preferring it to the uncouth group of white men boozing and idling back at the Club. Yet I am not sure if Veraswami returns these sentiments, herein lies the first instance of topsy-turvy-ness in this text: Veraswami, unlike Aziz, does not harbour disdain for the white man. Instead, he adores them; he envies the “prestige” of being one, and wonders “if only I were a member of your European Club…How different would my position be!” Perhaps what he seeks in Flory’s friendship is only the accompanying prestige of being in the presence of a white man?

Similarly, Ma Hla May quite obviously doesn’t need/want Flory for love (she already has Bo Pe), yet clings on to him all for prestige: “It was the idle concubine’s life that she loved, and the visits to her village dressed in all her finery, when she could boast of her position…” Consider also U Po Kyin, (who for some strange reason reminds me of Kim Jong Il!) backstabbing his fellow countryman Veraswami just so he could enter the Club, again, to raise his prestige.

The tables seem to have turned on white-ness as it has now been reduced to a commodity; a “white accessory” to borrow Melissa’s term, as something for the natives to exploit. Funny how Veraswami corrects Flory’s griping that the Europeans have come to rob by saying “…at least you have brought to us law and order”, which raises two new questions: first, did not the ‘natives’ exploit the colonisers in their own way and second, can we say that Empire was not such a bad thing after all?

(304 words, and whee~23:51, just made it!)

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

No sides worth taking

Orwell seems to have achieved the effect of resisting the reader’s sympathy with either side of the colonial divide in “Shooting an Elephant”. I say this because the narrator speaks from a very personal point of view, and harbours disdain for both the Empire and the natives. Thus it is difficult for readers to treat him as an allegory for the collective Empire, or as the embodiment of sympathy towards the natives.

The narrator exposes the Empire as mercantile and unfeeling: the elephant is comparable to “machinery”. Also, colonial rule seems to have no real function other than to keep up the “mask” of colonial rule. The colonist then becomes “a sort of hollow, posing dummy” and has to “spend his life in trying to impress the ‘natives’...” At the same time, the narrator is also unkind in describing the natives: they are as a “sea of yellow faces above the garish clothes”, demonized (corpses “devilish”) and infantilized (overly excited over a “bit of fun”).

However, these descriptions of colonizer and colonized are not pitted against each other in the manner that other texts we’ve been reading do. There is no significant interaction between the two sides, and the anecdote is focused on the police officer and his personal fear of losing face. All our sympathies as readers are channelled into the elephant, murdered violently and unnecessarily. With so much attention on the elephant, the usual concerns of colonizer-versus-colonized are sidelined. The materialistic, mercantile approach that both sides take to the death of the elephant disallows us to see one as more moral than the other, and Orwell might perhaps be trying to say that there really are no sides worth taking, and colonial rule has been outdated and rendered useless.

(291 words)

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Jim in Limbo

Edvard Munch, The Scream, 1895.    

This picture aptly conveys my general frustration with reading Conrad. With Heart of Darkness I found him excessively verbose, and although Lord Jim had a few bits of beautiful, poetic passages that I really loved, still, like Yuen Mei quipped, I kept getting lost in all the dialogue. My personal feelings aside, the second reason why this picture relates to Lord Jim for me is because of the overwhelming sense of crippled-ness in the text. 

Things seem to always hit a wall and fail here. Jim is a kind of cripple himself, having been injured by a falling spar. In Chapter 7, "[S]uch an overwhelming sense of his helplessness came over him that he was not able to produce a sound" (77). The sense of crippled-ness and things failing in the narration culminate to a point of frustration that screams silently out of the text, like the scream you can almost hear in Munch’s painting.   

But this picture also evokes a sort of limbo/liminal zone that figures in the text also occupy. The sea-farers occupy a liminal “existence between sky and water” (16), and the Patna is a mixed identity ship. Also, the narrative opens in medias res, and things are not revealed to readers in a linear fashion, even though it is narrated through a third-person omniscient narrator. Jim is also constantly in limbo between dream and reality. He is so caught up in his hero fantasies that he goes into a hissy fit when Marlow potentially insults his character.   

Relating this to modernism, perhaps all this silent screaming/crippled-ness stand for the modernist frustration/disillusionment with rapid technological progression and increasing social ills.   

(276 words)

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Africa through the Viewfinder

In my Asian American Literature class, Prof Walter Lim used the idea of camera resolutions to talk about Amy Tan’s problematic portrayal of the Chinese in The Joy Luck Club. In brief, Tan easily depicted America in “high-res”, providing details, whereas China was in “low-res”. She could only give rough sketches and generic descriptions.

I am aware the issues are not the same as in Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, but I believe the same concept applies. Conrad seems to have only one type of description for the natives: they are “brutes”, “savages” and black figures walking around. His depiction of the landscape of the Congo is also generic, and it seems the only valuable thing he has to say about it is its “darkness” or its ominous and mysterious air, always shrouded in yellow fog. Very “low-res” indeed. I must disclaim that I am not here to attack Conrad’s racism, only to point out that his depiction of the natives is so one-dimensional and generic, while full details are provided for White characters, such as Mr. Kurtz.

I feel that this “high-res”-“low-res” way of viewing things is still prevalent in our world today. My church had a Christmas musical one year based on a song by Scott Wesley Brown, called “Please Don’t Send Me to Africa”. I remember feeling disappointed to see that this modern day musical still had Africans dancing around in nothing but sticks and banana leaves. In this sense, Achebe is very right to say that the media today still gives us pictures of Africa as exotic, tribal, primitive, other-than-West. Despite travel documentaries that depict a wider, more humanised sense of African nations today, the ones looking through the viewfinder are ultimately still the collective West, no?

(290 words)

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

$$$

Reading Fanon's "On Violence" has got me thinking about the terms "Modernism" and "Postcolonialism" in another way tonight.

But let me first say the first half of the essay was rather pessimistic and dreary to read! Generally, "On Violence" came across as a very angry and vengeance-seeking text, and Fanon's constant reiteration that violence is the only way the colonised can break free of the colonisers' grip was like another gloomy touch to an already gloomy (rainy) Thursday evening. This is obvious when he writes that "between oppressors and oppressed, force is the only solution" (32), or that there exists only a "single combat between the colonized and the colonist" which is "clearly and plainly an armed struggle" (42). Surely violence could not be the be-all and end-all?

As a result of all this pessimistic talk about violence, I began searching the text to see if Fanon offered an alternative to violence. Surprisingly, Fanon does offer such an alternative, which actually makes him sound rather schizophrenic. I wonder if he deliberately started the essay pessimistically for dramatic effect. The second half of the essay suddenly shifts its focus to the practical plight of the nations seeking independence. This is where the term “Postcolonialism” took on a new meaning for me. “Postcolonialism” has always had the connotation of nations seeking independence struggling against their colonial masters, but now I am thinking also in terms of post-colonial; of what literally happens in real time and real places after colonisers withdraw from the colonised nations. For example, Fanon astutely points out that these young/new nations seeking independence are facing difficulties from all sides - the immediate problems of a sudden withdrawal of law enforcement, administration, infrastructure and capital (i.e. $$$), and also the gargantuan task of having to build their nation all over again:

"[W]hat we actually see is the colonizer withdrawing his capital and technicians
and encircling the young nation with an apparatus of economic pressure." (54)

They also face the challenges of etching their presence in a modern (and this was where “Modernism” took on a different meaning for me too), capitalist world. The young nation “sees the modern world penetrate the remotest corners of the interior, he becomes acutely aware of everything he does not possess” (34).

So instead of violence, Fanon seems to be proposing (if I'm not mistaken!) an alternative that might actually help the de-colonising nations. He proposes the "redistribution of wealth" (55), and then goes on to list his many grievances against the colonisers' "capitalist exploitation" (55), saying how "[c]olonialism and imperialism have not settled their debt to us once they have withdrawn their flag and their police force from our territories" (57). I thought this all made sense, especially relating back to Passage. After all, what are the British in Forster’s India without their native slaves to wait on them; what is their military if not for the Indians who enlisted and made its numbers?

However, I have a problem with this money-as-compensation proposition of Fanon’s. How is it possible to measure in dollars and cents years of invasion, exploitation, forced slavery and many other immeasurable forms of “violence” that the colonisers have done to the colonised? How much money will ever be enough to soothe such anger as Fanon's? He claims that “moral reparation” (58) is not enough, and immediately I think of today's developing African nations that are receiving plenty of NGO and UN aid, but are nevertheless still heavy in debt. The thing is, how can money ever right moral wrongs? Now, Fanon sounds just like the Indians in Passage who keep demanding poor Adela compensate her accusation of Aziz, and it leaves me wondering if these new/young nations, in their bid to re-create themselves, fall in the same trap everyone, coloniser or colonised, gets caught in: the trap of Capitalism.

-edit- Melissa (refer to post above) says empire is all about space. I think empire is all about money!

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

The Severed British Net

Hi all,

In the spirit of discussion/treating this blog as a forum for the exchanging of ideas, I would like to respond to Samantha's post for my entry this week, partly because the quotes she used in her entry were precisely what jumped out at me too.

Samantha states, 'I think we've undergone that same kind of ideological colonization through 'english-style education', and are still trapped in it today to a certain degree.'

Dr Koh, in reply to Samantha's post, wrote 'I wonder, so what do you think of the 'educated Indian class' vis-a-vis the Raffles schools and boulevards of Singapore? Does it indeed 'contaminate', or does it create a subservient class?'

My response to this is that the two outcomes offered, 'contaminat[ion]' or the 'creat[ion of] a subservient class', are too restrictive- I would like to propose that a third outcome, that can be seen in the context of Singapore, is possible: that another step towards the evolution of a national identity is taken.

Unlike Samantha, I do not think that the existence of current Singapore roads with British names indicates that we are still caught by the British 'net', but that they are instead simply markers of our colonial past. I do understand the discomfort one may feel from the knowledge that the memory of the oft-exploitative British remains today (street names, statues, school systems, etc). However, I feel that re-naming the streets Lorong Merlion just so that it is distinctly Singaporean (opening Pandora's box- what is 'distinctly Singaporean'?) results in a sort of historical amnesia, where we deny the fact that we were once a British colony. I think these vestiges of British influence are, while sometimes frustrating, essentially a part of Singapore today. In fact I could perhaps go so far as to say that the very fact that these British markers still exist encourage me in a warped way. They show that Singapore has progressed- insecurities no longer plague one enough to feel 'Alamak, British reminders everywhere, cannot cannot, must be nationalistic'. This sort of nationalism is, to me, unthinking and extreme; I am encouraged that we can today look at these roads and influences and feel secure in our identity as Singaporean, even if that means we remember that we were once a British colony.

Perhaps I come to this with a personal agenda- I am Peranakan, and since taking Prof Holden's module on Singapore Literature in my first year, I have felt a push to interrogate my own 'Singaporean-ness' like never before. We learned about how the Peranakans benefited pretty well from being under British colonial rule (as compared to other locals). They were often middle-class locals who took most easily to English customs, including the English language, and were often in civil servant positions. Effectively, they were people strategically used by the British to further their interests in the region, perpetuating the Anglicization of the country through local help. After learning about this in greater detail, I started seriously questioning how 'authentic' of a Singaporean I am- after all, my first language is the language of the colonizers. I can't say I fully understand my position still, but I have at least gotten to the point where I realize I cannot rail against the fact that my forefathers were arguably un-Malayan/Singaporean, that they belonged to a class that was created by the British for British ends. Bemoaning this would be unproductive and denying it means the denial of fact. I think that it is more productive instad to acknowledge this past and accede that the British left some of their entrails behind (sorry for the hantu penanggal image) even after Singapore attained independence. And that even whilst this may be true, we can simultaneously assert that these remnants in no way diminish our credibility as an independent nation, and as a country with a national identity that is constantly re-imagined.

As a side-note, I suppose this is why I am so interested in post-colonial, especially Singapore, literature- it (arguably) acts as aspirin for the colonial hangover.

Please let me know if anyone has any thoughts. I should also probably say that I'm not usually this 'RAH RAH GO SINGAPORE'.

Thanks!

-Kelly Tay

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

The British in India

Hello hello :)

As I was reading Levine's "Britain in India" and trying to link it to the narrative of Passage, what struck me the most about Levine's essay was the bit where she says:

"...in the 1830s there was considerable debate over the wisdom of encouraging an English-style education among Indian elites...British interests lay with whether or not an English education would secure the long-term loyalty of this essential class of administrators...Without the work of Indians...British India simply could not have functioned" (69).

and also:

"Macaulay...argued that English should be the language of state in India, and that westernization would improve the condition of India and guarantee the loyalties of India's educated classes" (71).

I'm sure that educating Indians so that they could be equipped to serve the British was a necessary measure and happened for practical communication purposes. However, doesn't this make the "educated" Indians go through (for lack of a better term) second colonisation? Not only are they colonised physically [the land of India], they seem to now be undergoing ideological colonisation by studying "English-style". Come to think of it, our Social Studies textbooks in secondary school seem somehow warped. We know that we were a former British colony, but our textbooks seldom speak of our colonial experience in a negative light. In fact, the British were often praised and exalted! Think of Sir Stamford Raffle's looming figure at Singapore River... Think of how we were taught how well the British planned towns, how efficiently they administered and governed. Think of how esteemed Raffles Girls' Secondary and Raffles Institution are in Singapore! Somehow, I think we've undergone that same kind of ideological colonisation through "English-style education", and are still trapped in it today, to a certain degree. Our exams are certified by Cambridge, we have "Speak Good English" campaigns, and our unique Singlish is severely frowned upon (please never let Singlish die out, it'd be such a waste). Remember how Aziz found that "[t]he roads, named after victorious generals and intersecting at right angles, were symbolic of the net Great Britain had thrown over India" (Passage 14)? I think Singapore in many subtle ways is still caught under that kind of net. We even have Clive Street (named after Robert Clive), not to mention Hasting and Minto Road as well. Street names probably don't amount to much, but it's as if these names were like the British colonial ghosts still staking their claim on our land... hmmm.

Also, I found the last line of the passage I quoted from p.69 particularly ironic. For all their strength, might and hold over India, the British colonists actually had to depend on the "natives", the Indians. They were their odd-job labourers, their armed forces; they were their surrogate butlers. To me, the irony lies in that British strength in India is not actually British strength, but Indian strength. (If I may insert a crude, if not simplistic analogy + digression here, I am reminded of the table tennis matches in the Olympics that just passed. The logic doesn't quite match up, but I am just somehow reminded of my friend remarking that watching Li Jiawei play against China was like watching China vs China instead of Singapore vs China. I mean sure, yes, we can say she's officially Singaporean and all, but it just doesn't feel the same!) Anyway, back to what I was trying to say: if we can consider educating the Indians in the British style to work for the British to be a form of anglicizing the Indians, then the quoted passage reflects a certain anxiety over such anglicization. Aziz represents for me a fully, but not successfully anglicized Indian. He's well-educated, speaks good English, and knows British customs well ["I know everything about you" (130).] But his loyalties lie far away from the British. In fact, he seems anti-British most of the time. I'm reminded again of Levine's "Ruling An Empire" chapter, where she writes that Indians assimilating into British society "was considered contamination, not assimilation" (107). Characters like Aziz seem to pose such a "contamination" threat to the British in Forster's novel. For example, people like the Turtons look upon Mrs. Moore's friendship with Aziz in disdain. In the courtroom scene, we see how prejudiced the British are against Aziz, even though he had not yet been proven guilty. All in all, the more I read about the British in India, whether as described by Levine in her essays, or as narrated by Forster, the weaker and more caricatured they seem to become.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

Self and the Other

Hello!

Like Chitra, I also preferred Auerbach’s reading to the other two, and I particularly enjoyed the way he teased out the various stylistic trends in Modernist writing - attention to consciousness, the seeming lack of authorial omniscience and the more fluid/fragmented treatment of time – all from a mere short passage from Woolf’s Lighthouse! However, I noticed something happening in my sub-consciousness as I was reading “The Brown Stocking” (I wonder if it happened with our classmates as well?). As Auerbach expanded on the different stylistic tools Woolf had adopted in order to explain the characteristics of Modernist writing, I found myself comparing each tool with pre-Modern writing, for instance, Victorian novels. In other words, in order to better grasp what Auerbach said Modernist writing was, I imagined Victorian writing as its direct opposite; as its Other.

This rang a bell for me later when I read Levine’s essay, especially where she says “the immense sense of difference and alienness experienced by Britons living abroad in other cultures is something many memoirs of imperial service mention” (107). She writes of how the colonizers look down upon the colonized as barbarians, savages, superstitious and uncivilized, as though they were “children in need of saving from their own ignorance and moral poverty” (120). The colonizers could define themselves as superior selves because they were not their native Others; they could congratulate themselves on being technologically, morally and intellectually more advanced when they compared themselves to their subjects’ lives. This theme of defining Self against the Other came up once again in Gikandi’s essay, where he highlights how, ironically, Picasso’s selfish and insensitive fascination for the Other, “fine African head…became a catalyst for modern art” (456).

For the Britons, separating themselves from their subjects in a selfish hierarchy might have been the only way they could register their sense of superiority and supremacy. Much has been written on how Modernism arose as a social reaction, perhaps deliberately separating itself from its preceding Other is what gives Modernist writing its unique stylistic characteristic. After Gikandi’s discussion of Picasso, this Self-Other dialectic really seems to pervade much; from the way people write, to art, and I suspect it reaches even to the way we order our own lives.

I like the way Auerbach reflected: “For there is always going on within us a process of formulation and interpretation whose subject matter is our own self. We are constantly endeavouring to give meaning and order to our lives in the past, the present, and the future, to our surroundings, the world in which we live; with the result that our lives appear in our own conception as total entities” (549).