Showing posts with label aesthetics of violence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label aesthetics of violence. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Fanon, Forster, Violence

Fanon’s ‘On Violence” makes quite an exciting read. The never-ending violence between the colonizer and the colonized, the strategies they each employ against one another, and how the colonized undergoes a transformation (from “thing” to man) during the violent process of decolonization.

However, putting Fanon and Forster together, Forster’s A Passage to India is not as violent, but a rather nullifying experience. Forster has this knack of building up dramatic tension only to flatten it. The expected climatic experience after all that dramatic tension is not fulfilled. If we read Fanon into Forster, I would say that the trial of Aziz would have been the linchpin to the violent process of decolonization, but it was not.

“The Marabar Caves had been a terrible strain on the local administrations; they altered a good many lives and wrecked several careers, but they did not break up a continent or even dislocate a District” (223).


However, we do get a sense that decolonization is in its infancy. Aziz’s victory made the Indians “aggressive. They wanted to develop an offensive, and tried to do so by discovering new grievances and wrongs, many of which had no existence" (245). Also, the victory led to a unification of sorts between the Hindu and Moslem (251). There are several changes on the colonizer’s side too, such as the Political Agent no longer having as much power and influence as before (280)

Yet, it is always made clear that the violent decolonization process is not going to happen.

"British officialism remained, as all-pervading and as unpleasant as the sun; and what was next to be done against it was not very obvious" (245, 246).

The colonizer’s Repressive State Apparatuses are still in place, in the form of surveillance.

"The Criminal Investigation Department kept an eye on Aziz ever since the trial -- they had nothing actionable against him, but Indians who have been unfortunate must be watched, and to the end of his life he remained under observation" (279).


Although decolonization is not happening on a large social scale, we do see the character of Aziz develop from a “thing” into a semblance of a “man”. I say ‘semblance’ as Aziz did not become the radical and violent colonized rebel suggested by Fanon. Aziz merely affirms his cynicism of his oppression as a colonized subject. Looking back, he acknowledges that “[t]his pose of ‘seeing India’ which had seduced him to Miss Quested at Chandrapore was only a form of ruling India; no sympathy lay behind it” (292).

I think that Forster has presented a far more realistic account of decolonization as compared to Fanon. I quite agree with the possibilities that Fanon suggests with regards to the whole decolonization process, but it is unsatisfying as it is also reductive. Fanon’s decolonization process is like a step-by-step “An Idiot’s guide to Decolonization”, colonized and colonizer relationships are over-simplified as he views them both as items/objects/units (inflexible), rather than humans (flexible). What disturbs me most is perhaps that he does not consider the forging of friendships/relationships/love etc between the colonizer and the colonized possible other than a violent relationship. He argues that the colonized is always waiting for a chance to replace the colonizer, whereas Forster suggests to us the possibility of a union between the colonizer and the colonized.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Response to: Aesthetic of Violence

What I understand to mean by the term “aesthetic of violence” is giving form, shape and meaning to violence, which in turn, attempts to rationalize and intellectualize what would otherwise be considered an irrational and intangible act.

Irrational because violence begets violence. There is a sort of senselessness in the cycle of violence in Fanon’s essay; “Terror, counter-terror, violence, counter-violence”. (47) An endless chain of reactions with no end in sight. This irrationality of violence is further reiterated when Fanon states that “colonialism is not a machine capable of thinking, a body endowed with reason. It is naked violence and only gives in when confronted with greater violence.” (23)

The intangibility of violence arises from its close alliance to the almost primal instincts of Man- “the colonized’s way of relaxing is precisely this muscular orgy during which the most brutal aggressiveness and impulsive violence are channeled, transformed and spirited away.” (19) Here, violence is seen as a raw impulse that escapes the bodily confines.

Modernism, in its attempts of representations and re-presentations, proceeds in a similar fashion with the aestheticizing of violence, in the sense that both seek to give form to something, which ultimately, lies beyond our grasp. There are countless blog posts about polyphonic voices and the “knowability” of things which touch on this particular aspect of modernism adequately. What I would like to add, is perhaps for us to consider Plato’s Theory of Forms (my very basic understanding of the theory, might I add, through past class seminars) into our discussion on Modernism. This is particularly so, when dealing with Forster’s A Passage to India and the notions of a “real” India (interestingly enough- all countries start with a capitalized letter). Simplifying his theory- it basically states that all objects that we see are mere copies/imitations/shadows of an original. This implies that what we perceive are mere representations of the Real- which is precisely why the “real” India eludes Adela or Mrs Moore.
(Side note: I find the idea of echoes within Forster's text particularly interesting with regards to this. An echo is a reflection/mimicry of the original sound. The echoes made in the Marabar Caves are however, unrecognizable as it sounds nothing like the original- a resounding "boum". This makes it all the more disconcerting to Mrs Moore and to me as well. And yet, I can't wrap my mind around the idea of why Forster makes the echoes as such- existential anxieties aside?)
Is it safe to suggest then, that it is with a certain sense of self-awareness that modernist writings take to only presenting traces of that which lies beyond our perception in the first place?